The Hiring Edge
Smarter hiring. Stronger teams. Better careers.
Hosted by Josh Matthews — founder of TheSalesforceRecruiter.com — this podcast gives you the real-world edge to grow teams and careers in tech.
Whether you’re a leader trying to build high-performance delivery teams, or a professional navigating the career ladder, Josh delivers no-fluff insights through solo episodes and raw convos with top minds across hiring, leadership, and career growth.
You’ll get:
- Proven frameworks for hiring, scaling, and retention
- Talent trends, AI tools, and recruiting tactics that actually work
- Career advice to help you stand out, level up, and move fast
- Culture and compensation strategies for real growth
Built for founders, tech leads, HR pros, and ambitious professionals — inside and beyond the Salesforce ecosystem.
New episodes every other week.
Watch on https://joshforce.com/YouTube
Subscribe now — and get the edge on both sides of the table.
The Hiring Edge
The Neuroscience of Learning, Teaching, and Hiring
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Your brain is great at making hard things feel easy. That's exactly why so much workplace training falls flat. Plus: the interrogation technique that gets honest answers in a job interview.
David Lieberman (Gravity Learning) joins Josh to unpack the neuroscience of learning, the psychology of defensiveness, and why most training is designed backwards. They cover:
• Why onboarding collapses under bullet points, and what research says to do instead
• The neuroscience of freezing under pressure, and the only thing that unfreezes you
• "Setup and pass," how to get people talking without fear of failure
• Why behavioral interview questions reward fast talkers, and the cop/interrogator trick that gets real answers instead
• The line between ethical influence and manipulation
• Active listening, done right, and why the version you were taught is fake
If you hire, train, or lead people, this changes how you do all three.
Salesforce Staffing: https://thesalesforcerecruiter.com
Gravity Learning: https://gravitylearning.com
Cold Open And Show Setup
Josh MatthewsAnd where are you coming from? Why were you going so fast? It's not asking for the entire story. It's just, let me get this little bit, let me get this little bit. And now that person's feeling like, oh my God, this is my paint. That's the corner. I'm heading right into it, right? Welcome to the Hiring Edge, the podcast helping leaders navigate the age of AI, create teams that thrive, and build a workplace people never want to leave. Today's guest is David Lieberman. He is the founder and chief learning officer for Gravity Learning, where they help organizations improve how leaders hire, develop, and bring out the best in people using science-based approaches to behavior and decision making. His work focuses on turning findings from psychology and neuroscience into practical tools leaders can use in the moments that matter most. And I gotta tell you, I really enjoyed this conversation and I'm confident stick with it. I think you'll learn a lot.
Why Experts Forget What Beginners Need
SPEAKER_00And what's interesting is things that used to be hard to us, you know, when you feel yourself going like, mmm, that's what triggers the reinforcement of neuropathways. You know, the neuropathways grow more dendric spines, so the connections are better, they become more insulated, they they cable almost, so they become more dense. And now that knowledge is easier to be reached. And what's interesting is when we reach knowledge that used to be difficult for us, and now we're hitting it easy, we get a dopamine drop. So, I mean, all of this adds up to we forget our experience, and something that used to be hard to us is now easy, and we're rewarded for thinking that it's easy, which is great for solving problems, but horrible for teaching. Sure. This is especially yeah, right. And this is especially prevalent for um onboarding. Right. Even the best teachers, when they're onboarding, they forget that they're teaching and they just share a bunch of knowledge. Right. So of course, people get super overloaded. They're drinking from the onboarding fire hose, and and it just doesn't work. Right. I mean, for organizations that consider onboarding a checkbox for maybe some sort of legal requirement, I mean, okay, I guess, right? And if you want it to work, the research is really pretty clear. Like the most effective onboarding sessions, um, focus on what are absolutely the most important things for people to know. Treat those like a real learning experience. I mean, the same sort of way that we teach people how to have difficult conversations. That's how you treat those parts of onboarding, right? Where there's interaction and talking and predicting of the future, that sort of thing. And then everything else is teaching people where they can go find what they need to find. Right. And so one of your major learning points is okay, so if you needed to find this, where would you go look? How about that? If you need to go find it, where would you go look? Right. So you're hammering the most important skills. And one of those most important skills is where do I find all of these other things that are usually covered in a million bullet points?
Josh MatthewsLet's let's keep going, man. Um, you're just talking about treating education and learning like knowledge transfer when it sounded to me more like it needs to be emotional and it needs to be possibly experience driven or story driven or getting people into a sort of thought pattern of this, then this, then this. And here's the big aha and the emotional uh I'll just say like dump, you know, the whether it's the dopamine dump or the adrenaline dump or like whatever it is that sort of cinches up those neural pathways. Is that basically what you're saying?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, basically that's right. I mean, the idea that when we have experience, that experience creates an emotional response. And the emotional response plus the experience and then the knowledge is what leads our brain to seat that knowledge. If somebody just gives you knowledge, shh, there's so much missing from the normal experience. I mean, we're we're not built as a species to sit down and learn a thing, we're built to have experiences. Right. And that's where most facilitators, even people who are really gifted, they go wrong. Right. So for example, with Gravity, we we were started by superstar facilitators. And so when our hiring strategy is to cherry pick the best ones that we can find from other places or out there on the web who also have experience, like neuroscientists or uh you know director level leaders and above. And even those people who are really amazing at it don't create the same kind of experience that we need to have created because it's not natural to us as human beings. Right. So if you're a hiring manager or a training manager, what's most important is building some sort of framework that your trainers can learn to follow. And it won't feel natural to them because it's not. Our natural way is just to tell people knowledge. You know what I mean? Uh and so when we learn to follow the natural way of absorbing information, it becomes so much more effective.
Josh MatthewsSo can you walk walk us through a like like I'm guessing you've got some TED talks that you've listened to and you're like, oh man, I remember that thing. And like it's it's stuck with you, whether it was the visuals or the style or whatever it is. There's gotta be some things that you see that like the people who are best at getting this across do. What are some of those
Teaching Feedback Through Experience
Josh Matthewsthings?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah. So great, great. So for example, let's say that you bring in a new manager. And maybe you, as a leader, have read studies that say feedback is number one for motivation, which by the way, it is. If you give people good feedback and then let them go, that's really what motivates human beings. And so you want these people to give feedback that's aligned to the research. So you say, look, here's the way you do it. You focus on behavior first, and then you tell them the impact of that behavior so they know what you're talking about and why it matters, and then tell them what to do instead or to keep doing that. Right. You go, okay, but it doesn't really connect with us as human beings. If you are going to create an experience, instead, you usually start that experience with a problem. And most of the things we learn, we don't learn because, you know, learning is fascinating. We learn because there's a problem in our lives. Right. So if you were to think back at the times where you received feedback and it wasn't that helpful, or when you receive feedback and um you wanted more or better feedback, and we've all had leaders that didn't help raise us up. Right. Now you're in a like, oh, that's interesting. Like you're you're there, right? You've started to create an experience. Normally, when you have experiences, we talk about it. Right. So if people share with somebody else like what happened to them, now we're really there. Our our our working memory is going very strong. Right. Now it's time to present a solution. You know, that that model that I was talking about before, if you can come up with an acronym, by the way, that works, a good acronym, not one that makes it harder to think about, man, it's seats. Right. So for feedback, we we do big feedback, behavior, impact, growth.
SPEAKER_01So this sounds very familiar.
Josh MatthewsI I'm sorry, just for jumping in. I thought it was a pause, David. Um it sounds like NLP to a degree.
SPEAKER_00Sort of anchoring people in so no and NLP is is has lots of different little parts to it, but certainly one of the parts is creating an experience and then anchoring that experience. Yes. Right? Because now it's become something real to us. Right. So when when you learn a thing, that's not enough. This is probably the biggest problem during live training that most people skip. Man, if you never rehearse it, you're never gonna do it ever again. You know what I mean? And so people tell you a thing and expect you to keep it. At gravity, we don't we don't role play. We don't say, This is Sandy. What would you say to Sandy? You know, we rehearse. When you rehearse, you know, we all know the more you practice, like the better you get at a thing. And when you're rehearsing, you're practicing in real life. So let's say you do a thing and then you talk about it, and then you make plans to use it in real life that have a like a who and a when associated with it. Now we've just turned the likelihood of that knowledge turning into actual behavior change. Sure. A huge percentage is gone up. Right. So to roll it kind of up, um, normally that cycle is start with a problem, have a discussion, learn a thing, try it out, talk about your experience, make plans to use it. And in real life, the first time you use it, the whole thing sort of starts over again. You look at it and you judge how it went and you you roll through that learning experience.
Josh MatthewsYeah, makes it makes sense. That you hit me with an anchoring, right? Because it's this is so whether you're in sales or you know, if you're selling something, or if you're uh David Letterman. A lot of these uh uh late night talk show hosts do it. Someone would make a joke. I remember one time he says, Got any gum? And everybody laughed because it was a funny joke. And every dead spot during the rest of the program, he'd just look at the audience and go, got any gum? And everybody would bust out laughing. And they just anchored them to this one joke. Comedians do it all the time. And I suspect really, really good trainers do the exact same thing.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah, it's it's a reinforcement, right? And so what's really going on neurologically is you're again hitting that neuropathway, right? When we go, huh, somebody says remember, and you go, huh, that's the signal for your brain to reinforce this thing in the same way that if you lift something heavy, it's a signal for your brain to go build more muscle, right? So comedians are doing that, salespeople do it, right? I I know someone who's a real estate agent, and he waits until someone says something that they really like, and he just sort of slowly fades that back into the conversation over and over again as it returns them to
Anchoring And Reinforcement In Training
SPEAKER_00that moment. And teaching and training is the same thing.
Josh MatthewsIs do you think anyone like there's this really thin line between helping someone learn, but you're you're really using techniques that are highly effective techniques for education and and for retained learning? But it those same skill sets can be utilized for manipulation, right? For changing someone's mind, for selling something that somebody doesn't want, right? So I'm kind of curious like how well vetted is the information that's that's being conveyed that it's like super supportive, because we've always got like you guys are doing some amazing things, but I'm kind of curious, do you ever feel like you are utilizing these practices that you've been studying and working on and building a business around for years? Do you feel like they have pervaded your personal daily life? Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Well, you know, it's a yin-yang thing. On one side is manipulation, and on the other side is giving people information or treating them the way that we are naturally set up to be treated. Right. If we can teach in a way that naturally absorbs, great. If you bend someone
Influence Versus Manipulation In Real Life
SPEAKER_00to your will in a way that naturally makes them say, okay, maybe not great. I mean, on one hand, you could manipulate me into a trip to Hawaii and I'd be all for it. Right. And so the idea is that once once you have these skills, they're really human behavior skills. And of course they per they pervade into other parts of your life. I sold a house about two years ago, and I told the real estate agent, hey, just so you know, I'm gonna be here to walk people through the house. And they did not want me to do it, right? They were all afraid that I would be weird or pushy. And what I wanted to do was connect with what I know about humans to point out why this place is so great. And so one leads to the other as we move through, and and that's kind of the beauty of it is as learning professionals, everything that you learn sort of stacks on the next thing.
Josh MatthewsWhat drew you to this? Are you the accidental learn adult learning expert because you fell into it? Or did you wake up when you were 16 years old or 20 years old mid-college and go, you know what? I'm sitting here in class and this sucks. And there's gotta be a better way to learn than this. Did you have a moment like that?
SPEAKER_00You know, um, we do my mother was a teacher, and now my brother is a college professor. And so, you know, you can say that there's a nature-nurture thing going on. And for me, I always enjoyed figuring things out and being like, oh, that's interesting, and then talking to people about it. And um, while I was going through college, I had a greeting card business. They were all sarcastic cards that I thought were amazing when I was 19 years old. Uh there were things like, um, you know, last year I got you something, you didn't like it. This year I didn't get you anything. How do you like that? Right. And and this was back in the uh early days of uh computer design. And so I took a class on on the page maker, it was called. And and the teacher who was teaching, I was like, that looks like fun. Later, when I went through a career shift, I went to school for clinical psychology and after a while decided that isn't the right thing for me. I was looking at like, okay, what can I do? And I saw an ad for that same school. And I, you know, focus on Photoshop and things like that. And I went down there and I said, I know Photoshop, and they were like, You're hired. And I remember walking home and thinking, I like my job. That I I would have done that for free. It was like such a weird thing, you know what I mean? And um, and through that, I became incredibly interested in figuring out how teaching works. Right. Of course, after a while, we pivoted, I pivoted out of software and fell into leadership positions and uh of small and then medium and larger size teams and fell back into learning and development, where now in the professional skills area, not only could I figure out how these things work and test them, because I was also in leadership positions, but craft and teach other teachers how to teach and it was is really pretty fantastic. You know, one of the things that stuck with me from the clinical psychology days uh is the prevalence of research. And really what that turns into in our field anyway is credibility. Right, because I mean, everybody's had some HR person stand up and go through a bunch of bullet points telling you what you should do. And especially for thinkers or skeptics, if nothing else, the information isn't that deep. Right. And so what we do is base everything we do on jury journal professional peer-reviewed studies. We don't say research shows, we we tell stories of the research, right? Because it's again creating experiences. Right, right. But when you're able to say, hey, this comes from a study published in the International Journal of Cognition and Work, and the researchers were interested in how do we get stopped? Like, why do we freeze as human beings when we get into sticky situations? And so they did this and that, and then they found out this thing, and here's what it means. Now, even the most skeptical audiences are interested as they move forward. And it's that I want to know what it means. Tell me. Yeah, yeah. Well, great. It it turns out that that reaction of when someone says something crazy, uh, or when you're in a sticky situation at work. Uh for example, I mean, the further you go up in leadership, the more those individual moments matter. When somebody sees you shine in a tough situation, wow, like leadership presence is a real thing, isn't it? Yeah, and diversity, if they see you fail, what's interesting is once you move past middle management, almost 25% of promotional decisions are based purely on presence. And weirdly enough, it's more for women than it is for men. And presence is made often in those little situations, right? So understanding what to do in those tough situations, let's say that you and I are sitting around a table and we're both senior VPs at an organization, and there are other senior VPs sitting there, and there's the CEO. And now you say something that's just straight up wrong. For me to go, um, that's wrong is kind of a weird situation. It puts you on the point. And so here's what's going on neurologically. In my brain, I sense danger, and there's this little part in your brain underneath your thalamus, uh, called the subthalamatic nucleus. If you love cool phrases, it throw around at parties. Lights up real hard when we're in danger. And the measurable like behavior is that we freeze.
Josh MatthewsAnd is the freezing just to buy time? I mean, is that just to get the prefrontal cortex back online and make a better decision, or is this still all in the thalamus?
SPEAKER_00So, what evolutionary biologists think, they're pretty sure about it, but they think that it's an evolutionary response to danger. Right? If you're walking through the woods and a bear comes out, you don't fight or flight the bear, you you stop. Right? And unless you're a park ranger and now you know what to do. And so then you do that thing. And so that feeling of uh is an evolutionary response to keep you alive. Right. So to say, like just chill out or be confident, that's not how it works. The only thing that they know Yeah, right. Yeah, the the researchers that look into this type of stuff, the only thing they can find that'll release you from that is knowing the steps. Right. That's why it's so important for your audience that if they build training for their organizations or hire someone, inspirational speakers, and it feels really good, doesn't it? But it doesn't work because a couple of days later it drifts away and there are no steps that people can follow. They certainly haven't learned.
Josh MatthewsThere's about 40 or 50,000 of us that are there right now because it's now uh Wednesday, and two weeks ago, uh 40 or 50,000 of us were at Dream Force. And all that love, man, all that, all that camaraderie, all that motivational, inspirational keynotes, Tony Robbins, laughter with Jim Gaffigan. You know, you you get you get home and you feel that vibe for a few days, but by Monday of the following week, you know, eight days later, it's it's not there anymore. It's really what's left is what plans have you made and is it on your calendar to execute based on everything that you you know that you figured out at that time? And so it's so critical to capitalize on those emotions at the time, do something real. Can I ask you something?
Lowering Defensiveness In Live Learning
Josh MatthewsUm, like Tony Robbins talks about this a lot, about getting into a certain state, being in a position where you're um open to learning, which I imagine requires some amount of vulnerability because we have to shut off our I know better than you uh signal, right? switch, or the I don't want to get pulled into having to stand up in front of all of these people and answer a question, sort of like class fear, blackboard fear or whiteboard fear. Is there some sort of regular thing that is done that is recommended in a live training scenario to get people into that learning space? And I'm gonna give you a part two on this. What about with online learning? How do you do that? So what you're talking about is very, very real, right?
SPEAKER_00Defensiveness has been around for a long time. By the way, you know who came up with the the idea of defensiveness? Sigmund Freud. That's how long it's been around, right? It is one of his big things. And so the research around defensiveness is that we don't get defensiveness. About what we've done as much, but about who we are. And so if we're made to look bad or if we think we failed, it's it's our image that we as teachers need to watch out for. Right. And and social fear when you're doing things in front of people. Do you know the number one anxiety-raising like thought pattern? It's it's public speaking. Yeah. When you're in front of everybody, you know what I mean? Uh they think that's because, yeah, right. Um, when everyone's looking at you, that's a biologically dangerous point. All all social pack animals perform some sort of ostracization where they kick out a member and that member usually dies, right? And so we as teachers are calling on people. Shh, that's a real dangerous moment. Right. And so there are some techniques that you can use or that your leaders can get their trainers to use. Um, here are a couple of big ones. Awesome. It is really important to get people to engage and interact and feel involved. Right. When when you get them to interact and feel involved, it's super important that there's not a wrong answer. If you have them do something in front of everybody, if there's any failure point, danger, danger, danger. And and what's interesting is it's more valuable to get them to talk about their thoughts or what they're noticing. And we all have thoughts and we all notice, right? Here's a technique that we teach to our facilitators. It's made specifically to avoid all of that yuck yuck. Uh it's called setup and pass, and here's how it works. Um, the most important part is in a learning environment, we've all seen it where you say, uh, maybe you can tell us what you think. Um, Josh. And Josh goes, and then has to say in front of everybody and don't pick me, don't pick me, don't pick me. I wasn't paying attention, right? If if instead you start with the name, if you say, Why don't we reach out to Josh? Josh is awake now. And Josh, maybe you can say a little bit about what you think about what we're talking about. I let you off the hook. It doesn't need to be a big speech. Josh? Right? So it's it's name first, and then a can't fail topic to talk about with a release from having to be impressive or making a big speech. It really, really works.
Josh MatthewsDavid, when we when you and I first talked uh like a month ago uh about being on this show, you taught me something that was fascinating that falls into this same category. It's at least adjacent, which is I think you had shared that even if someone has a question, and at the end of a class you say, any questions, even if someone has a question, it takes them six seconds to sort of come up with like, uh yeah, I do. And it takes about 12 seconds for the people who don't have a question yet, but but will. And yet the any questions pause is typically only about three seconds. So by saying the name first, you're bringing their attention, and now the clock is ticking and their brain is working to kind of orient that. Oh, I'm going to say something. What's it gonna be? I'm a little okay. I don't have you bring the fear down, it doesn't have to be a big fancy, hyper intelligent insight. We're not trying to put you on the spot. We just kind of know what what do you think? Keeping it nice and loose like that. So it sounds like that's blended. It's buying time as well.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's it's both. You're turning on their brain and letting them think. And some people need a little bit of time to think before they get going. Right. And it's also making it an easy answer. And and frankly, it's more educationally valuable anyway to talk out your thoughts. We use seven to eight parts of our brain when we're talking that we don't use when we're just thinking.
unknownRight.
SPEAKER_00And the more neurologically active we are, the better neurotransmitter uh can become like insulated and reinforced. So you I mean, you could make the point that you're literally smarter when you're talking. We've all figured stuff out when we just start talking about it, right? And um, and the other important thing is if there is something that people could struggle at, um, they struggle away from the group. Right. So if you're doing online training, which there's a ton of now, and you're going to have people rehearse something new, they do it in breakout rooms, not in front of everyone.
Josh MatthewsRight, right. So this is sort of that that praise in public and uh you know correct in private. Um I I do. Yeah. Yeah, struggle, yeah, yeah, yeah. No, that makes sense.
Hiring For Presence Beyond Smooth Answers
Josh MatthewsThese leaders who really make it up to the top, right? These folks, what recommendations or advice or scenarios or behavioral setups, behavioral uh interview scenarios and setups would you or do you recommend when hiring managers, whether they're a board member, CEO of a $10 billion company or a $5 million company, doesn't matter, when they're trying to screen for the folks that have that presence, and it's not just the perfectly rehearsed response for that question. Because we all know, like, there's a difference between being a good interviewer and a poor performer, right? What do you recommend? Yeah. What do you recommend?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, we we do have a workshop that we used to call hiring the perfect employee. We had to change the name because people are like perfect. And what what we're really trying to do is find a great fit. And and the research is pretty clear that there are a couple of things that are really important. Right. So, for example, in the industry, behavioral questions are super popular, right? Because if you figure out what someone's done in the past, that's a pretty good predictor of what they'll do in the future, right? Except what you said is so, so true that if you're good at talking and you're fast on your feet, you can figure out what they're trying to ask you and make up an answer. Right. I'm I'm sure you could do it if I said, tell me about a time that you struggled at work with another employee and what you did to bring the relationship back together, right? You could come up with something right now that didn't happen, that sounds really real, that makes me score you very highly on our rubric.
Josh MatthewsYeah, I've got real examples though, but okay.
SPEAKER_00I'm sure you do, right? But but if you didn't, or if you're a person who kills relationships, but you're fast on your feet. Right. So those questions are less valuable than we think they are. What we end up like hiring are people who are they seem good, and then when it really starts happening, you're you're flummoxed. Why are they acting like this? Yeah. So what you might consider doing is the same thing. We're trying to find out about real behavior, except we break that question down into steps that makes it much less likely for people to just make something up. Right. So for example, uh, I might say something like, you know, uh, I was just thinking about like uh we we have a difficult client who threw a major change into my life the other day. Like, you know how it is, you've had difficult clients before, right? And they're like, Yeah, you're like, uh, can you tell me about one? Give me a difficult client, right? So they just agreed that they had one. Yeah. Right, which probably sparked a thought. And now I'm asking them to tell me about that person. So they tell me about a thing. And if they don't, then tell me what they did. Now I can say, Well, what did you do? And the likelihood of a real experience coming out is so much stronger. It's it's interesting. I've I've performed interviews where people told me about like a story about them not performing in a way that made them look good at all, right? Because I pulled a real situation out of David.
Josh MatthewsThis is the exact same technique that interrogators use in uh the police and the FBI. It's it's literally no different. And most of us, if you've been on the planet with a car for 20 years, you've probably been pulled over at some point or another. And it's where are you where are you headed to? Right. It's the very first question. It's the it's just to like get you to talk and hopefully say something that um it it can be used against you later on, right? You can be caught. So where are you going to and and where are you coming from? Why were you going so fast? It's not asking for the entire story. It's just let me get this little bit, let me get this little bit. And now that person's feeling like, oh my God, this is my paint. That's the corner. I'm heading right into it, right?
SPEAKER_00And and they're pulling out things that are kind of inconsequential and real. That's right. Right. Earlier you were talking about manipulation. And it kind of strikes me that you're manipulating someone into giving you a more honest answer. Is that bad? Or are we just connecting with how humans work?
Josh MatthewsYeah. I mean, that's connecting with how humans work. You know, manipulation, I think by design has to be not a win-win situation, right? Someone is benefiting while the other person is either not benefiting or is losing something, right? Or is having to make a decision that is not actually in their best interest because uh other additional information has been obfuscated or uh hidden in manipulation and persuasion, it's called trickery, right? That's the actual that's the technical term is trickery, meaning that someone is led to believe a certain thing that isn't necessarily the case. And you can you could have all the words there and be like, but I never said that, you know, and maybe they didn't, but the way human behavior works, as you know, I mean, it's not like a silverbacked gorilla has to use his words to make an opponent back down, right? It's like, but you didn't say anything. It's like I stood there like this, and you you got scared, and I showed my teeth, and you got scared. Like it doesn't, so this is where it gets, you know, we we start getting more into uh physical behavior and and physical communication.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, we're all complicated, aren't we? And like I think you're right that it's a lot about intent and about whether or not something good is happening for everyone. Yeah. Right. So so that that's one of the big ones is it when you directly ask a behavioral question, you're going to get people making things up. Walk them towards it with, oh, you know how that happens? And they go, yeah. And then ask them to tell you about a time and then what did they do? Right. And the other one, the other one's really interesting. Um, you know, we have a conversation with someone to decide if they'll be good at a job. But we don't often have them do the job, right? One of our uh clients is the head, uh, the senior VP of an IT organization. And they would interview people and they seemed perfect on paper, and then they would get them in and they couldn't do the things that they expected them to be able to do. Because they never said something like, Everything's looking pretty good. We're gonna set you in this room for 45 minutes and rebuild the server. When they started building a real work test, they found that some of the people that they would never have hired were people they decided to hire, and vice versa. You know, often when people hire executives, they give them some sort of little project to do. Of course, if you're auditioning for a TV show, they make you show the work. Yeah. But most other hiring managers don't have a way to prove you're actually good at this thing. And it's maybe the most important part.
Josh MatthewsYeah. Well, it is. You know, the proof, proof of actual work is really the key. Now, keep in mind for the technical part of the job, right? For the technical part of the job. Because yeah, if they're hiring a DBA that's gonna be locked in a basement, um, just working on SQL and data analytics all day long. Yeah, okay. If they're never gonna talk to a stakeholder, they're just gonna look at tickets and knock them out, like that's a totally different thing. So the talking matters, right? The communication matters, that ability to be patient. Are they listening? I just had this this week. A pretty high-level position. I had two candidates. Both of them couldn't answer the never answered the hard questions directly. They gave theory, not past experience, right? And I mean, it's not the end of the world, right? It's like, hey, you know, you could kind of bring them back into the fold, but when it happens second time, third time, fourth time, it's like, okay, so this is a pattern. So we can hire this person. We'll know that when we ask for the specifics, they're likely to go to the generalities or go into theory instead of just tell me what came up on the computer. What did you see? What did you do about it? You know, that's much more important. And you might not want to hire that person.
SPEAKER_00I think you're saying something really important that the technical skills, the things that are checked on the resume are often what we use to decide whether or not someone's qualified. And often it's the people stuff that really becomes the problem or the shining achievement later on. It is. What we recommend is developing three different work tests, the things that are most important and to make sure that at least one of those parts are people parts, right? Because even if you don't interact with customers at all, you're still interacting with people around you. And, you know, for example,
Active Listening That Builds Trust
SPEAKER_00even just the ability to listen, maybe, maybe the most important people skill, period, is the ability to show someone that you've listened. What's what's fascinating is that most trust in leadership is about whether or not that leader has clear expectations. And most trust from leaders is whether or not the leader believes you know what they want.
unknownRight.
SPEAKER_00That's what makes your leader trust you. And if you haven't proved to them that you heard them, that you listened, how how can they know that you know what they want?
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_00And the same thing happens in interviews, right? It's a we've all heard of like active listening where you say back to them what they said to you. Yeah, the reflection. Yeah, and that's not it at all. Like, unfortunately, that is a bastardization of true active listening. Uh, and one of the most important things that we bring to our participants, and frankly, you can learn it very quickly, is to stop playing that weird rephrase what they said, except in my own language thing, which actually makes you listen to less because you're playing a weird mind game. You're constantly thinking about it. Yeah, how am I going to say this? Right. And it's fake. You can see people doing it. So in instead, what you do is you check what you've understood in your head and you confirm that that's correct. Right. So if you start by saying something like, Let me let me make sure I'm hearing you right, or can I confirm that my understanding is correct, or can I check to make sure I'm getting it, or some kind of check of understanding, nobody ever goes, no. Every single person on the face of earth goes, right? Because we've all been misunderstood so many times. And it sounds like in those interviews that you were going through, if that person stopped and said, Let me make sure I'm understanding what you're asking me and what you're hoping that I say, even if they got it wrong, you would have said, Well, not that really. And and that person's a listener.
Josh MatthewsYeah. This solves so many problems. I mean, look, most problems I believe, my my belief is that most people either have uh communication problems or philosophy problems. Like their beliefs are grounded in something that's not it doesn't make sense, right? Um, and we're so people are so different. Some of us clearly we make decisions based on how other people are going to feel, and other people lean more towards making decisions based on what is true or apparently true or logical or makes the most sense, or possibly the greater good, or whatever it happens to be. And that is going to create conflict, you know, when you have people with two different design patterns in their head about arriving at a decision. So that's already a problem. But then if they can't communicate that, that's a problem. But we talk about like the importance of the ability to communicate, but we don't talk about, and I think, and I could be wrong, I think most people think about communication as output. And they don't spend enough time thinking about it as input into your own head or through your ears or through your eyeballs, what you're reading. And our ability to actually see what we're reading or hear what's being said is so it's so important, right? I found that often people can, you know, let's say I I I'm trying to express a concept and the person's not getting it. Now I'm thinking they're not getting it, that's their problem. You know, they're thinking this person isn't communicating the right way. That's their problem. Right. So now we've put now everybody's got a pro now everybody's got a problem. And it's one of the hardest things, David, and correct me if I'm wrong here, to try to imagine like people, some people are better at putting themselves in other people's shoes. I think very few people are really good at putting themselves in another person's brain because you're just laying your own logic and your own decision-making process on the inputs that that other person had in whatever scenario they were. And of course, you're coming up with a different idea of what would have been right and what would have been wrong.
SPEAKER_00If I'm hearing you're right, you're saying, like, look, we've got our own beliefs and knowledge, which of course get filtered through our own lens. And then we figure out how we're going to say it, which of course changes things, and then we say it, and then it's interpreted in a certain way and filtered through someone else's own beliefs and knowledge, and then they do the same thing, it comes back to us. We've had what, six now different filters and opportunities to change the message. And when someone, when somewhere there's a misalignment there, we don't think about that process. We think there's something wrong with that person, is our natural way of doing it. Is that basically what you're saying?
Josh MatthewsExactly. And that was a beautiful demonstration, David. Thank you for doing that. That is the clip of the day.
SPEAKER_00Right. But but but you're 100% correct. And what's interesting is, you know, there are a lot of studies about things like uh inclusion and how we behave to accept the difference in others. And what's interesting is that most trying to teach people to do that fails horribly. In unless there are a couple of different things. One of them is the thing that you mentioned, it's perspective taking, right? The ability to put someone else or put ourselves in someone else's shoes, which is really hard. There's not a huge evolutionary advantage to me thinking about you, right? There's a huge evolutionary advantage to me thinking about myself. Right. So as we do it, and the more we do it, like everything else, it rehearses and reinforces that behavior and becomes easier. But then what's also interesting there is it's not necessarily just about putting yourself in that other person's shoes. It's about, okay, what do I do now? Like, what are my steps? Right. We're back to like what are the steps again.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_00So maybe the steps are think about how they might be different than you and then check your understanding of what you're hearing before moving on. Right? It's a two-step, three-step maybe process. Right. Um what's what's also fascinating that your leaders might find interesting is that human beings do not have a really big capacity for lots of steps. That no, there's research that started in the late 60s about how many things can we keep in our head at the same time. They called them cognitive chunks. And it turns out for ideas and steps, when you pass about four, it starts getting really tough. Yeah. And what's really interesting is we have a strong, strong connection to three. If you really want somebody to learn something, it's it's one, two, three, like good, better, best, gold, silver, platinum. One, two, three, go. Like we have an easier time remembering uh chunks made of three than chunks made of one. Often like um Larry, Curly, and Mo is easier to remember than Larry. Because of association. Yeah, and because we kind of we have this weird grouping with three. There's like holy trinities
Perspective Taking And Simple Steps
SPEAKER_00that stick with us.
Josh MatthewsYeah. Yeah. Yeah, that's f like wow. I never thought of that. But that yeah, that's fat that's fascinating. I love that. Yeah, so David, it's it's it go ahead.
SPEAKER_00No, please. I was gonna say, I think that you're hitting on something really important, and that's why personality tests are so big with so many people, especially in the the learning world. They love that stuff, and it all kind of boils down to like, hey, people aren't all like you. So the more you can obsess about hold on, people are different than me. Whether or not they're like eight or four different chunks, Carl Jung is the person who started that kind of stuff. So it goes way back again. To me, I don't think it's super important about which system that you're really into. When you focus on it for a while, it becomes easier. That's the neuropathway behavior towards perspective ticking.
Josh MatthewsThat makes sense. I've I have subscribed MBTI since I was 18. That's really you know, I know that there's new science that I know that there are improved psychometric evaluations, and I do use them with my clients from time to time because they're they're just fantastic and gives you more insight, not just, you know, which of the 16 personality archetypes or profiles are you, but what kind of stress are you under right now? How are you behaving that's different? Like, what's the drift between how you're behaving and what your natural behavior is? And and some of these tests can can highlight that, which I find incredibly fascinating. But for day to day, I'm asking myself, is this person extroverted or introverted? Like where's their battery and where's their self? What how good is their self-dialogue? Right? How are they making decisions? How long do they take to make decisions? In other words, what what does it feel like for them after decisions have been made? Great or crappy, right? Regardless of the decision, right? Um and and things like that. Just that helps me to put myself in other people's shoes and I'll find out basically what are they hiding? Because we're all hiding something. We all have masks. We put on one of the big, we put on one of our biggest masks during interviews, right? So I've always viewed my job is to at least remove one or two of those masks because they're stacked up, man. They're really, they're really layered.
SPEAKER_00You know, we all want to put our best foot forward. You know, when we talk about candidates, I know that some places use personality testing. What's what's interesting is uh one of the most statistically significant uh personality tests, um, and by significant I mean predicts actual behavior, uh, is one about conflict. It's called the Thomas Killman instrument. And they one of the reasons they think that that's such a significant test is because it recognizes that we're not always like a certain way, that we generally have kind of a go-to behavior and then a backup as well. Right. So for example, um, I I might be the type of person that you know is totally willing to engage with you and argue and go back and forth. And when I say might be, like I'm like that, right? But I definitely have a backup that I fall into when that doesn't feel safe or appropriate. And so if we're looking at personality tests and trying to find out like who fits best, it's not just what their normal go-to way is, it's how they behave in other types of situations where that one's not really, you know, safe or appropriate.
Josh MatthewsYou know, this idea, let me ask you this. Do you believe that the backup the backup system is just not as fundamentally trained, right? And I'll give you an example. Uh there's someone who doesn't stand up for themselves very often. Let's say that they are more they lean more towards submissive than dominant in in their, you know, in in their character. And then when they choose to become, let's say, more, I don't want to say aggressive, but you know, stand up for themselves. They've so so little practice in it that it's uh the words are violent. The word, you know, the the the way that they do it, it's sort of wreaks havoc. They're trying really hard. It's good for them, you know, it's good for them. And I mean, this happened, you can see this. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Just reinforced. Well, I mean, all conflict methodologies
Conflict Styles And Engagement Killers
SPEAKER_00that we use to navigate conflict, they all have positives, but they all have pretty big downsides as well. Right. So, for example, um, people who are passive, like what you're talking about, um, fall into a couple of different categories. And and it's why are they passive? Right. Some people, they're relationship driven, and to them, this thing that we're involved in doesn't really matter. I just want to keep the relationship going well. Right. But but if I give and I give and I give and you don't give, it's it's not that I'm giving, it's that I'm doing it for the relationship. I care about our relationship, don't you? So after a while that builds. And then we've often experienced people in relationships who have like a volcano explosion. And of course, that side of that conflict methodology is not going to serve you, right? But there's also people who are avoidant. They're like, you know what? No, thanks. It's just not worth it today.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Right. What they don't understand is that a lot of time people see them as like freezing someone out or giving them the silent treatment. And that's not what they're doing. They're just avoiding the conflict.
Josh MatthewsYeah.
SPEAKER_00And then when they decide, like, okay, it's too much, then they have different strategies that of course have positives and negatives to them as well. But I think you're really hitting on something that once we're driven towards action, our natural way of dealing with conflict, no matter what it is, has downsides. And if we don't have steps and learn what to do, we're gonna run into those downsides. Right. Like our culture tells us that the collaborative conflict person is the best one. Let's all get together and you know work something out that works for everybody. But there's problems with that too. One, it takes a really long time and can feel. I don't know if you've ever had a leader who was super collaborative. After a while, you're like, Can you just make a decision? Can we just move on? Oh no, it's but the other the other side of it is we think we're being all nice, but what we're actually doing is forcing everybody to like get into this system. Yeah, you know, where they all agree. So, you know, they all have downsides. Those types of people need to choose their battles in the same way that people who don't mind getting in there and arguing with you is a choose your battles type of thing as well. Yeah. When we do workshops in person, one of the great killers of engagement is people having their laptops out. I mean, you can't help it. You're gonna multitask. But what's interesting is that there is a study, I don't have the journal off the top of my brain, but like where they found that you on your laptop is worse for your neighbors' learning scores than they are for you. They don't know why they think it's like peripheral vision or lack of agency. You know, when somebody has their phone out in the movie way over there, right? Um, and and when people hear that it's more about your neighbors that you put the laptops away, then they go, hmm, and they slowly put it away. And there's such a stronger learning experience.
unknownRight.
Role Psychology During Change And Uncertainty
SPEAKER_00You also said something interesting about um, you know, Josh is the dad and Josh is the podcaster. And in uh in social psychology, there's a very strong theory that's been tested many times uh around role psychology, where we identify ourselves as a series of key roles. And if we're not meeting those roles or moving those roles forward in life, we become dissatisfied. But also, you know, in in the change workshops that we do, what's interesting is many change initiatives fail before they even start, or because people know something's coming and they don't know what's happening and they start kind of freaking out. And it's a role psychology thing. My role here at this organization, however I see myself, something's going to change and I don't know what's going to happen. And so sure. If you've ever heard a leader say, just keep doing what you're doing, you know, it's business isn't normal. That's because um, if you don't tell them, they stop. And it's a role conflict. I don't know how I'm supposed to behave in my role because things are changing. And so when leaders help people to reset role priorities, then people keep moving. We saw a ton of this in the beginning of COVID where people just froze. Yeah, and so that that role psychology is really interesting, isn't it?
Josh MatthewsIt's fascinating, and it's fascinating too, just from a leadership standpoint, how important it is to be involved and keep people informed and up to date. Particularly, I mean, the the ecosystem that I operate in is so rife with uh buyouts, businesses closing, businesses being purchased, consolidation, multiple new little firms popping up, consulting firms popping up like crazy. And of course, because I'm talking to candidates who are interested in looking for a new opportunity, they are often happy in their jobs, they like their jobs, but what they don't know is if they're going to have it in six months. That's right. Because there are rumors, right? Because there's uh PE is being investigated for um, you know, expansion, or there's a possible buyout with this other company, and they have the same kind of group, the same kind of staff. And what do they do about it? And when that communication from leadership stops, the worst is assumed. Of course.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's that's something really important that I mean, you probably know positive people, right? Except you don't or two positive people are a myth, right? We're all way more negative than we are positive. We have way more negative thoughts and we notice more problems. We remember negative experiences way longer. And so when you're going through a time of ambiguity or change and you're not over-communicating with what you know and what you don't know, uh people are gonna make things up. And the things they make up are not going to be good, right? They're not gonna say everything's probably fine, right? Yeah, we're finding now that there are we, you know, there are trends in the industry, and our clients are more and more looking for change and ambiguity management more than anything else. And the old like system of like change management is failing people because it was a plan, like let's get together and plan out risks and things like that, where really what's important now is the human aspects, right? The kind of stuff you're talking about. Yeah, it's it's it's more along like keeping people moving or managing expectations or you know, all that kind of kind of good stuff, you know, and um especially where we are right now, there's so much going on that's kind of up in the air with AI and you know, the political climates, and yeah, we're all in kind of a weird spot.
AI Era Persuasion And Where To Learn More
Josh MatthewsYes, we are. I mean, look, we AI is the new thing. Political climates have been at odds for uh uh centuries, you know, millennial, millennia. So that's not a shock. Um, but what is shocking is how much information is out there and how manipulative and overtly persuasive it is, and more importantly, how little, and this is where you can see I'm like, Josh is getting excited, okay. How how limited people's ability is to filter the words. I can filter everything you're saying, David. But when I read a news article, or when the average person reads a news article, are they able to filter out, okay, um this person it sounds like that's a sounds like a sound bite. I wonder if there is more behind this little quote that's in the headline in this clickbait.
SPEAKER_00You know what's interesting is I don't know if we were ever good at that. I think that there was just more limited ability to get out mass messages. Right. And so now not only is that ability much wider, people are leaning into the manipulation. Like they're doing it on literally on purpose. Like when you think about like people twisting their evil mustaches, there are algorithms running to like more engagement, more engagement, more engagement. And engagement, they figured out totally works better when you give somebody a shocking negative.
Josh MatthewsYeah. Right. Hey, there's crazy stuff happening. No, it's true. David, this has been a fascinating discussion. Like, I've really enjoyed this. I you talk about behavior and neurology all day. I've learned so much from you. I'm certain that our listeners and our viewers have as well. Let's have you share how people can learn more about Gravity Learning and about David Lieberman. Where should they go? Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So um, Gravity Learning is a research-based professional skills organization. And so we usually work with medium to large size organizations to bring in real professional development change. And um, and we're about the only org that gives proof point measurements on behavior change and impact and literal ROI. You can check us out at gravitylearning.com. My profile's there as well, or you can find me in Admi on LinkedIn. And we are kind of the crux of nerdy, interesting, fun, engaging, and actually works. Right. So uh I'd love to hear from your listeners and thank you so much for having me. Uh, these kind of conversations just push all my nerdy hot buttons.
Josh MatthewsSo mine too. Thank you so much, David. Have a wonderful week. Love to have you back on the show another time, too.
SPEAKER_00Thank you so much. My pleasure.